
Content creator Tori Winstead is a mom of two boys in Scottsdale, Ariz. Her claim to internet fame: not giving her kids snacks.
In August, Winstead — whose Instagram bio reads “less snacks more fun” — shared her no-snack stance in a now-viral post. “I stopped giving my 2- and 4-year-old snacks and this is what happened,” she says in the video, rattling off a list of improvements to her home life. She has a “cleaner car.” Her kids are “cleaning their plates” at meal time because their tummies aren’t full from Goldfish and fruit snacks. She feels “more sane and more free.”
In her posts, Winstead, whose professional background was in real estate, lays out the kid snacking culture she’s rebelling against. “I cannot go to the park without every single mom there having packed snacks,” she says. “It’s literally 10:30 in the morning and every single kid out there is eating puffs, granola, fruit, you name it.”
It’s driven her to go on a “snack strike.” “You’re hungry?” Winstead says in another post. “Good. Maybe you’ll eat at dinnertime.” (Speaking to Yahoo, Winstead clarifies she would never actually “deny a hungry child.” Says Winstead: “I believe children should eat real food when they’re hungry. My kids can have snacks if they are expressing hunger. … If they are hungry, I offer an apple, a meat stick or a piece of cheese.”)
Read the comments reacting to her social media posts, and you’ll find a mix of parents cheering her on (“I never bring snacks to the park,” one mom responded. “Only water. Them getting hungry is how I convince them that we need to leave.”), other parents defending their own kids’ snacks and eating habits, and pediatric dietitians weighing in to offer their guidance. So how did snacks become such a divisive parenting topic — and do kids need them?
No, says Amy Johnson, who runs the parenting site Amy Baby. “Kids eat way too many snacks,” she tells Yahoo, adding that “the store-bought snacks found in the U.S. that target children are typically unhealthy.” Like Winstead, Johnson has two kids. “When we cut out snacks, our kids eat better at mealtime,” she says. “We try our best to cram activities and events into the weekends so the kids don't even notice they are missing snacks, and eat better during lunch/dinner.”
Conscious parenting coach and toddler mom Blanka Molnar takes more of an “everything-in-moderation” approach. “Some parents are very strict and try to control what their kids are eating, and other parents are very laissez-faire with how and what their kids consume on a daily basis,” she tells Yahoo. “I am trying to find the balance, and there are days when things totally spiral out of hand.”
But parents who give their kids snacks aren’t just using applesauce pouches to console tantruming toddlers. Snacks are built into many kids’ daily routines, whether their parents like it or not: snack time at school, orange slices and Pirate’s Booty after soccer games, seeing another mom give out yogurt melts during playground hangouts. And nutritionists say the issue isn’t so black-and-white.
“Snacking, when purposeful and intentional, is a wonderful way to support kids to keep up their energy and meet their huge nutrient needs as they're growing,” says mom of four and pediatric dietitian Aubrey Phelps. “Unfortunately, so much snacking has become junk food [or] highly processed foods that offer calories but no real nutrition. It's also often on a whim, any time a child expresses boredom, hunger, etc., instead of as part of an intentional offer.”
Michaelann Rangel, a registered dietitian at Children’s Health, agrees that not all “snacks” are created equal. “Too often we can think of snacks as those foods associated with the ‘snack aisle’ — things like chips, crackers, snack cakes, cookies, etc. Those are what I’d call treats.”
Treats should be indulged in sparingly. Snacks, on the other hand, “should be thought of as a small amount of healthy food, eaten between meals to take the edge off our hunger and give our body more nutrition,” Rangel tells Yahoo. “Kids can choose to eat or not, but they should be able to trust that there is a relatively predictable schedule of when food will be available, and between those predictable times they have the opportunity to develop hunger.”
“Snacks are an important part of a child's diet, when consumed appropriately,” adds Kellie Allen, a nurse practitioner at Bluebird Kids Health. “That being said, snacks should complement meals rather than replace them.” She also warns against using snacks as a reward for good behavior or to distract a bored child. “If snacks turn into an expectation for treats, it may be time to reconsider if [it’s] necessary,” Thea Runyon, founder and CEO of Pediatric Health Coaching Academy, tells Yahoo.
Judging from the chord Winstead’s “snack strike” posts seem to have struck with like-minded parents in her comments, there are a fair number of families who simply don’t do snacks. For those who do, the experts who spoke to Yahoo have some tips for doing it in a way that doesn’t wreak havoc on mealtime. Phelps suggests having at least two hours between feedings. “For kids, the sweet spot is typically two to three hours to make sure they're hungry, but not Snickers-bar-commercial ravenous,” she says.
She also has some simple formulas for suggesting snacks that are decidedly not treats: “Protein plus fat. Protein plus color. Fat plus color.” That might be, Phelps says, a cheese stick with an apple, mixed nuts, Greek yogurt with berries or a banana with peanut butter and hemp seeds. If convenience is key, she recommends premade bars from Dino Bars or Skout Organic.
“The best foods to offer are minimally processed foods that offer nutrients to help our bodies: fruits, vegetables, eggs, beans, nuts,” Rangel adds. “Consider a string cheese paired with fruit, a boiled egg with sliced cucumbers, a yogurt topped with sliced almonds, a small cup of whole-grain cereal and milk, a slice of whole-grain bread and peanut butter, a granola bar with grapes, etc. Have several options available and let kids choose two things that pair well together for them.”
Winstead takes a sterner view. “Stop buying single-serve packaged snacks,” she tells Yahoo. “Full stop. Don’t go down that aisle, don’t put it in your cart. If you fear your child will be hungry when out and about, a great option is an apple.”
Allen suggests spacing out snacks or offering “lighter, more balanced” options “instead of cutting out snacks completely.” She adds: “We don't want to shame children for listening to their bodies telling them that they are hungry; we want to encourage intuitive eating and learning natural hunger and satiety cues.”
latest_posts
- 1
阪神 梅野がFA権行使せず残留「今から準備をして来シーズンに臨みたい」(デイリースポーツ) - 2
Most loved Fish Dish: What's Your Sea Joy? - 3
MLB激震 2投手が賭博で起訴…26歳右腕は逮捕 『不正投球』で4つの罪 絶対的守護神に後輩が加担 連邦検察が発表(サンケイスポーツ) - 4
Virtual Domains d: A Survey of \Inundation and Ongoing interaction Mechanics\ Computer game - 5
Sports Shoes of 2024: Upgrade Execution and Solace
60年前に発表のクレーンゲーム機クラウン602、情報提供呼びかけ…タイトー「当社の技術の原点」(読売新聞オンライン)
LUNA SEA・真矢、ルナフェスにサプライズ登場 12月にライブ開催を発表「少しでもドラムが叩きたい」(vois ヴォイス)
Top Pastry: What's Your Sweet Treat of Decision?
【最近食べた?】なぜ「ウエハース」は食玩でよく目にするのか? 人気の秘密をバンダイに聞いてみた(ねとらぼ)
Brave Climbing: Trails and Stuff for Outside Lovers
『ポケパーク カントー』来年2月5日開業で注意事項 ポケモン初の屋外常設施設で110段の階段を上れない人など入場できず(オリコン)
【独占】“史上最強”日本のエース・久保建英に柿谷曜一朗が迫る、W杯で一番上を目指せるチャンス「(確率は)今回一番高いんじゃないかな」(TBS NEWS DIG Powered by JNN)
TBS近藤夏子アナ、ラジオで妊娠生報告 産休&育休入りへ(オリコン)
「なかなか行けない場所」ツアー人気…清掃工場の操作室・空港の制限区域・銭湯の裏側などに「発見」求め(読売新聞オンライン)













